Middle Grade Ninja: Middle Grade Ninja Episode 05: Editor Mary Kole
To watch new episodes as they air, go to YouTube and subscribe.
Middle Grade Ninja is available on Soundcloud, Stitcher, itunes, Podbean, Podblaster, RadioPublic, blubrry, Listen Notes, Google Play, and many other fine locations.
Editor and former literary agent Mary Kole and I discuss her career in publishing and her approach to editing. She shares many tips for how to create memorable characters, how to improve a story’s pacing, how best to market a book, and all sorts of other invaluable advice for writers. You’ll want to revisit this episode a few times and take notes as it’s packed with great content. And do not forget to check out KidLit.com, MaryKole.com, and purchase your copy of Mary’s excellent book on craft, Writing Irresistible Kidlit.
As promised in the show, here is the text of the kind rejection I recieved from Mary back in 2010: “Thank you so much for the opportunity to read BANNEKER BONES. Unfortunately, this is a pass for me. The writing here is good and the premise is fun and interesting but I’m having a hard time imagining how to pitch or sell this in today’s market. The voice just isn’t 100% there for me, and it really has to shine for me to take something on. You’ve obviously a very skilled writer and I know I’ll be kicking myself, but I’m not connecting to the material enough to be the best advocate for it in the marketplace, and you deserve nothing less. I’m sure another agent will feel differently and I look forward to reading about your many successes. You’re plugged in and getting there, I can tell, but you’re not quite there yet.”
Makes sure you check out Mary’s original interview when she faced the 7 Questions.
- Recognize the differences between middle grade and young adult audiences and how it impacts your writing.
- Tailor your manuscript’s tone, length, and content to your readership.
- Avoid common mistakes and cliches that are prevalent in YA and MG fiction, in respect to characters, story ideas, plot structure and more.
- Develop themes and ideas in your novel that will strike emotional chords.

